Heartless by Marissa Meyer – A Whimsical, Heartbreaking Villain Origin Story

What happens when the Queen of Hearts was once… just a girl with a dream?

Before she became the red-tinged monarch of madness, Catherine Pinkerton was a bright, creative young woman. She dreamed of opening a bakery and filling Wonderland with sweetness instead of fury. However, as Marissa Meyer shows us in Heartless, dreams can be dangerous in a world ruled by kings, jesters, and fate.

Sourced from Pinterest; Artist: @lauilustra

This standalone young adult romance reimagines Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland through the eyes of the woman who would one day scream, “Off with their heads!” But before the crown and the rage, there was love.

The Heartless Story: A Taste of Wonderland, Bittersweet and Wild

Catherine is everything a future queen shouldn’t be — kind, independent, and brimming with dreams that defy expectation. The King of Hearts wants her hand in marriage, but she desires flour, sugar, and butter. She wants to create joy, not rule with power.

Then she meets Jest, the court jester with golden eyes and secrets deeper than the Looking Glass. Their connection is instant, intoxicating, and forbidden. As Catherine’s choices pull her between passion and duty, the story’s whimsical surface gives way to a slow descent into tragedy — a villain origin story you’ll feel in your chest long after the final page.

Meyer’s writing dances between charm and melancholy. Every scene is painted in wonder: talking animals, twisted tea parties, and dreamlike dialogue that perfectly captures the offbeat magic of Wonderland. Yet beneath it all, there’s an ache — the sense that fate is closing in, and no amount of frosting can sweeten heartbreak.

Artist: Unknown; Sourced from Pinterest

Tropes & Themes You’ll Love

✨ Forbidden Love

💔 Villain Origin Story

🍰 Follow Your Dreams vs. Duty to Others

👑 The Price of Ambition

🖤 Found Hope, Lost Love

At its heart (pun intended), Heartless is about the delicate line between innocence and corruption. It explores how love, when denied or destroyed, can twist even the kindest hearts.

Tone, Pacing, and Style

This clean YA romance unfolds at a gentle, steady pace. The beginning feels light and playful, showcasing Catherine’s charming optimism and the whimsical absurdity of Wonderland’s inhabitants. However, around the halfway point, the tension begins to build, layer by layer, until it culminates in a dark, gut-wrenching finale that transforms sweetness into sorrow.

Marissa Meyer’s writing remains beautifully accessible and engaging. It’s ideal for readers who enjoy Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber or retellings with a fairytale flair.

Who This Book Is For

✔️ You love villain origin stories that explore the humanity behind the monster.

✔️ You crave romantasy with slow-burn tension, emotional depth, and lush worldbuilding.

✔️ You prefer clean romance that delivers heart without spice.

✔️ You enjoy the whimsical, dreamlike chaos of Alice in Wonderland but want a story that tugs at your heartstrings.

💔 Who Might Not Enjoy This Book

If you’re looking for a happily ever after or a fast-paced, high-stakes fantasy adventure, Heartless might not be your cup of tea (pun fully intended). This story leans into melancholy, not magic battles. It’s a tale of love lost, dreams crushed, and the making of a villain — and it hurts in the best way.

Sourced from Pinterest; Artist: Unknown

The Journey of Catherine Pinkerton

Catherine's journey is not just about love; it’s about self-discovery. She grapples with her identity and what it means to follow her heart. The pressures of expectation weigh heavily on her. The King of Hearts represents the life she is expected to lead, while Jest embodies the freedom she craves. This internal conflict is relatable and poignant.

The Role of Fate in Wonderland

Fate plays a significant role in Heartless. The characters often find themselves at the mercy of circumstances beyond their control. This theme resonates throughout the narrative, reminding readers that sometimes, despite our best efforts, we cannot escape our destinies. The whimsical nature of Wonderland contrasts sharply with the harsh realities the characters face.

The Impact of Love and Loss

Love and loss are central themes in Heartless. Catherine's relationships shape her into the person she becomes. The love she shares with Jest is beautiful yet tragic. It highlights the fragility of happiness in a world filled with chaos. As readers, we witness the transformation of Catherine from a hopeful dreamer to a heartbroken queen.

The Symbolism of Baking

Baking serves as a powerful symbol in the story. It represents Catherine's dreams and her desire to create something beautiful. Each ingredient holds significance, reflecting her hopes and aspirations. As her journey unfolds, the act of baking becomes a metaphor for her struggle to find joy amidst despair.

The Legacy of the Queen of Hearts

Catherine's transformation into the Queen of Hearts is a cautionary tale. It warns of the dangers of unfulfilled dreams and the consequences of choices made in desperation. Her legacy is one of heartbreak and loss, serving as a reminder that even the most innocent hearts can be hardened by life's trials.

Final Thoughts

Heartless isn’t just a retelling; it’s a reminder that sometimes the people who break the most were the ones who loved the hardest. If you’ve ever wondered what made the Queen of Hearts so… heartless, this gorgeously tragic, whimsical novel will give you your answer. It will make you ache for her long before she ever picks up the crown.

💌 P.S. Want More?

If you loved this review, make sure you’re subscribed to my newsletter! You’ll get future book reviews, romantasy recs, and behind-the-scenes insights into my own stories delivered straight to your inbox — like a love letter from one bookish heart to another. 💕 Subscribe below. 👇